Virginia Tech has unveiled the first scientifically validated rating system for construction hard hats and helmets, setting a new benchmark for worker safety in the industry.
The Helmet Lab at Virginia Tech — long known for rating football, hockey, and cycling helmets — has applied its expertise to construction headgear after more than a year of testing. The research, released Monday, shows a striking difference in safety between standard hard hats (Type I) and helmets with interior padding and side protection (Type II).
According to the findings, Type II helmets reduce the risk of fall-related concussion by 34% and skull fracture by 65% compared to Type I models. The study simulated real-world accident scenarios, with fall impacts ranging from 14 to 25 feet — far beyond the industry’s current standard of testing from just 2 feet.
“You do everything you can to avoid hitting your head first,” explained Barry Miller, director of outreach for the Helmet Lab. “That meant 14-foot to 25-foot falls create impacts similar to plunging from 5 to 7.5 feet. That’s a lot higher than the industry standard of testing 2-foot drops. I think we’re better at simulating real-world accident scenarios.”
The result is a star rating system from one to five for 17 helmets tested, offering construction firms and workers a clear safety benchmark. Out of nine Type II helmets, seven earned five stars, while most Type I helmets received only one or two stars. “It’s the first real data set that says something concrete,” Miller said. “Type II saves lives.”
The project was partly inspired by tragic real-world incidents. Construction veteran Scott Greenhaus, who was present at the 2018 Florida International University pedestrian bridge collapse, recalled the aftermath:
“When we got to the site, we noticed their hard hats were all lying on the ground where the structure came to rest,” Greenhaus said. “So we looked into it and said, ‘Wow, we’ve got to change the way we do business from here.’”
Greenhaus, co-founder of the advocacy group Hard Hats to Helmets, believes the rating system is a pivotal step toward a safer construction culture.
“We’ve got to change the way we do business from here,” he emphasized, noting that widespread adoption of higher-performing helmets could prevent fatalities and raise awareness across job sites.
Virginia Tech’s team emphasized that developing ratings for construction helmets is more complex than sports gear. While football helmets protect against repeated hits, construction helmets must withstand high-impact, unpredictable falls. The lab recreated accident conditions with specialized equipment, measuring head injury risk under various scenarios.
The rankings are already being hailed as a breakthrough in occupational safety. Contractors, unions, and safety advocates now have data-driven guidance to inform purchasing decisions, worker training, and future safety standards.
Virginia Tech’s Helmet Lab plans to expand its research to include more brands, models, and specialized protective gear over time. The university hopes its findings will influence not only equipment manufacturers but also industry regulations, potentially raising OSHA standards and employer requirements for protective headgear.
By quantifying protection levels for the first time, the system provides both workers and companies with clear evidence to support a shift away from outdated hard hats toward modern helmets. As Miller put it:
“It’s the first real data set that says something concrete. Type II saves lives.”
Originally reported by Zachary Phillips in Construction Dive.
.webp)
